We are closed at the moment. Ordering system is disabled.×

Our reviews

(10 Reviews)
Your trust is our top concern, so Old Astoria Pizza can't alter or remove it's reviews.

Do you like Old Astoria Pizza? We appreciate your effort in writing about your experience. Help customers like you make an informed decision.

Write a Review


September 01, 2026
I got in a late order and on the phone and the personal size pepperoni pizza was perfect for me. They were open when many restaurants in the area were not. Thanks for the dessert!


August 25, 2026
Recently moved to town - didn't know what to expect. This pizza was outstanding! Old style, dripping with cheese and generous, flavorful ingredients and sauce. I'll be a regular.


August 25, 2026
The pizza was quite good and the crust was amazing. Tasted like a flaky pie crust.


August 23, 2026
Fresh and delicious!


August 18, 2026
BEST PIZZA EVER!!! This place is incredible!! The selection/choices are outstanding! The owner sure is awesome. It does take awhile- but I'm telling you- it is sooooo worth every single minute!! The crust/outer edge is unbelievable-like nothing I've ever had before!! Memorable!! Can't say enough!! The almost 50 reviews I read are almost all 5 stars--!!!!! Seriously dreamy food by an amazing great guy👍👌🤩😍❣️❣️❣️


August 10, 2026
Best pizza I’ve had in years! It was much appreciated after 2 weeks of traveling up the coast. Having my leftovers for breakfast right now! Thank you so very much!


May 25, 2026
I have been eating pizza most of my life (77 years old). This is hands-down, absolutely the best pizza I have ever had. The Caesar Salad was delicious. It’s worth a trip to Astoria.


May 20, 2026
Pizza was fantastic and little bonus marinara sauce was amazing!!


May 16, 2026
Smoked salmon pizza was a 10! Excellent and friendly service!


April 24, 2026
Fantastic pizza and sauce. Very friendly atmosphere and owner.
Write a Review